Russia and the European Union:

Between Partnership and Rivalry

Co-organizer: Renner Institute, Vienna Cooperating Partners: WeltTrends, Potsdam

Programm

Conference languages: German / English

Introduction

After the enlargement of the European Union on 1 May 2004, the shared border between the EU and the Russian Federation will extend for more than 2000 km. However, the close links between the EU and Russia are economic as well as geographical. After enlargement, more than 50% of Russia’s foreign trade will be conducted with the EU, while Russia is the EU’s sixth-largest trading partner. Half of Russian oil exports flow to the EU, meeting around 15% of the EU's needs in imported fuel. Yet a corresponding political partnership between these two neighbours – which are both undergoing major transformation processes – has still to emerge. Both partners’ internal development processes are highly unpredictable, and expec-tations vary widely on both sides.

Although the European Union is now promoting the “Wider Europe” concept with the EU as the central actor, its capacity to act in the foreign policy field is limited and is likely to be re-stricted further by enlargement and the temporary collapse of the European constitutional project. In the security policy field, Russia does not really take the EU seriously – despite progress on the ESDP and the adoption of the European Security Strategy, which defines contributing to stability in the EU’s immediate neighbourhood as a priority objective. There are fears in Moscow that Russia’s existing spheres of influence could be rolled back further by EU enlargement. In order to prevent a new Iron Curtain, the Russian Government is de-manding a visa-free travel regime, for example, but the negotiations on a facilitated transit procedure for Kaliningrad have proved extremely difficult.

Russia has been in the throes of radical political, economic and social transformation for more than a decade. The direction in which President Putin and his concept of “Managed Democracy” will take the country is still unclear, as are the Russian elite’s political objectives. The repeated calls by the EU and other European organisations (Council of Europe, OSCE) for Russia to come into line with Western standards – on democracy, rule of law and human rights – conflict with Moscow’s handling of specific risks such as the threatened further col-lapse of the country and terrorist activity, especially in Chechnya. The West also finds Putin’s foreign policy course hard to fathom. Having lost its superpower status, Russia has still not positioned itself clearly in the new world order, as the Iraq conflict recently demonstrated. What are Russia’s foreign policy goals, and how much weight does it attach to the EU in this context?

In light of the imminent Russian presidential elections and EU enlargement, the Development and Peace Foundation (SEF) has selected relations and cooperation between the European Union and Russia as the theme of its Potsdam Spring Dialogues 2004. The event will open with presentations on the two sides’ expectations of each other. The first session will then analyse the development routes that Russia could take after the parliamentary and presiden-tial elections and explore their possible impact on Russia’s relations with the EU. The aboli-tion of visa requirements is impeded primarily by the new and often-quoted “soft risks”, such as organised crime. The second session will therefore focus on joint measures to combat these soft risks, which in Europe can only be curbed effectively through interaction between the EU and Russia. The third and final session will seek to analyse current developments in institutionalising European-Russian relations and identify policy areas where practical coop-eration could be fruitful.

Thursday, 1. April 2004

19.00 hrs

Welcome and opening
Steffen Reiche
Minister for Education, Youth and Sport
of Land Brandenburg
Post-election Russia and pre-enlargement EU:
Two partners in transition

Opening speechers

Russia's expectations of the European Union
19.15 hrs Vladimir I. Seregin
Head of the EU Division
Ministry of Foreign Affairs
of the Russian Federation, Moskau
The EU's expectations of Russia
19.45 hrs Dr Eckart Cuntz
Head of the European Department
Federal Foreign Office, Bonn
20.15 hrs Plenary discussion
Chair
Dr Burkhard Könitzer
Executive Director
Development and Peace Foundation, Bonn
21.30 hrs Informal evening
at the Restaurant Hofgarten (Hotel Voltaire)
Friday, 2 April 2004
Session I:
After the parliamentary and presidential elections:
Where ist Russia going?
The presidential elections on 14 March 2004 are likely to reinforce President Putin’s position of power. He already has the two-thirds majority in the new Parliament that is necessary to allow him to amend the constitution and thus stand for a third term. From a Western perspec-tive, however, it remains unclear which political course President Putin will pursue from this position of strength. Will he continue the process of economic and democratic transformation and bring Russia closer into line with Western standards, or does his concept of “Managed Democracy” herald the re-emergence of a more authoritarian system? How does Putin de-fine Russian interests, and what will be his domestic and foreign policy priorities during his second term? Will he continue to seek closer relations with Europe or adopt a specifically “Russian” course, distancing Russia from Europe? And how much importance will Russia attach to Europe compared with the USA and Asia?
9.00 hrs Indroduction
Dr Irina Kobrinskaya
Executive Director,
Foundation for Prospective Studies and Initiatives
Leading Research Fellow, Institute of World Economy & International Relations (IMEMO) of the
Russian Academy of Sciences, Moscow
9.30 hrs Panel discussion
Dr Roland Götz
Head of the Research Unit
Russian Federation and CIS,
German Institute for Internatioal
and Security Affairs (SWP), Bonn
Professor Dr. Gerhard Mangott
Institute for POlitical Science
University of Innsbruck
Dr Susanne Scholl
Head of the
ORF-Office in Moscow
(Austrian Broadcasting Corporation)
11.00 hrs Coffee break
11.30 hrs Plenary discussion
Chair of Session I
Dr. habil. Raimund Krämer
Editor of the journal WeltTrends, Potsdam
Member of the Board of Trustees of the
Development and Peace Foundation
13.00 hrs Lunch
Session II:
A "common space for internal security":
a possible responts to new security risks?
Following an agreement on 31 May 2003, the EU und Russia are seeking to establish four “common spaces”, including a common space for internal security. Yet there is still no overall strategy for this project, and Moscow’s main concern remains the issue of a visa-free travel regime between the EU and Russia. But without effective measures to combat the new soft risks such as organised crime, human and drug trafficking, money laundering, illegal immi-gration and terrorism, the EU will not contemplate introducing visa-free travel. These security risks can only be tackled jointly, but major differences between the partners are emerging – notably when the fight against terrorism jeopardises democracy and human rights and rein-forces authoritarian tendencies. How can the EU deal with these differences, and which role can be played by other organisations, especially the Council of Europe, in this context? Which approaches to common measures in the area of soft security have already been adopted? Where is there an urgent need for action? And finally, where do the limits to joint action lie?
14.00 hrs Panell discussion
Rudolf Bindig MP
Spokesman of the Working Group on
Human Rights and Humanitarian Aid,
Parliamentary Fraction of the SPD, Berlin
Vice-President of the Parliamentary Assembly
of the Council of Europe
Bartosz Cichocki
Expert on Russia
Centre for Eastern Studies, Warsaw
Dr Peter Lock
Independent Researcher Coordinator
European Association for
Research on Transformation (EART e.V.), Hamburg
Dr Olga Potemkina
Head of the sector for regional studies
Center for European Integration Studies,
Institute of Europe, Russian Academy of Sciences,
Moscow
16.00 hrs Coffe break
16.30 hrs -
18.00 hrs Plenary discussion
Chair of Session II
Dr des Michèle Roth
Deputy Executive Director
Development and Peace Foundation. Bonn
19.00 hrs Reception
hosted by the Minister-President of Land Brandenburg
Wellcome
Barbara Richstein
Minister for justice and European affairs
of Land Brandenburg
Saturday, 3 April 2004
Session III:
From visions to action:
Policy areas for EU-Russian cooperation
There are already numerous cooperation frameworks and action programmes between the EU and Russia and new ones are being launched all the time. Yet Günter Verheugen, Europe’s Enlargement Commissioner, recently took stock of EU-Russian relations and con-cluded: “We have a great many action programmes but very little action. We have major strategies but no initiatives. We have visions, but little work in practice.” What changes must be made in Brussels and Moscow to ensure a more positive balance-sheet in future? Are there any common interests which can only be achieved through genuine strategic partner-ship? How can institutional cooperation be improved? And which specific areas are suitable for functional cooperation in future?
9.00 hrs Introduction
Dr Heinz Timmermann
External Research Fellow
German Institute for International
and Security Affairs (SWP), Cologne
9.30 hrs Panel discussion
Vasily Astrov
Economist
The Vienna Institute
for International Economics Studies
Gernot Erler MP
Coordinator of German-Russian Intersocietal
Cooperation at the Federal Foreign Office, Berlin
Dr Galina Michaleva
Head of the Yabloko Party's Analytical Center
Director of the
Center for Contemporary Political Studies, Moscow
Professor Kazimiera D. Prunskiene
Former Prime Minister of Lithuania
Member of the Seimas, Vilnius
11.00 hrs Coffee break
11.30 hrs Plenary discussion
Chair of Session III
Christian Meier
Research Unit "Russian Federation and CIS"
German Institute for International
and Security Affairs (SWP), Berlin
12.30 hrs Political outlook
Professor Peter W. Schulze
Senior Lecturer at the
Center for European and North-American Studies
Universty of Göttingen
13.00 hrs Closing remarks by the organisers
followes by lunch and departures

Nina Heckmann
Russia and the European Union: Between Partnership and Rivalry
Nina Heckmann
Russland und die Europäische Union: Zwischen Partnerschaft und Rivalität
Peter Lock
Abstract to Session II Transnational identities: boon or curse for European security?
Heinz Timmermann
Thesenpapier zu Teil III Von Visionen zu Aktionen: Rahmen und Politikfelder für europäisch-russische Zusammenarbeit und Partnerschaft
Irina Kobrinskaya
Abstract to Session I After parliamentary and presidential elections: Where is Russia going?

l.t.r. Eckart Cuntz, Vladimir I. Seregin, Steffen Reiche and Burkhard Könitzer

Diese Seite wurde über eine Suchmaschine aufgerufen. Die Website der SEF-Bonn wird dynamisch generiert und wird dadurch nicht von gängigen Suschmaschinen indiziert. Wenn Sie nicht in wenigen Sekunden zu der gewünschten Seite weitergeleitet werden, klicken Sie bitte hier